The Nocebo Effect: Is Social Media Making Us Feel Unwell?

social media mental health

Could the constant stream of wellness advice, health warnings and beauty trends on social media actually be making us feel worse?

We live in a world where we're more informed about our health than ever before. We can access information about hormones, gut health, inflammation, skin conditions, nutritional deficiencies and supplements with a few taps on our phones.

In many ways, that's a positive thing. Better access to health information can help us recognise symptoms, ask better questions and make more informed decisions.

But there's another side to this information overload that I think deserves more attention.

What happens when we're constantly being told that something about us isn't quite right?

That our hormones are out of balance. Our gut needs healing. Our skin barrier is damaged. We're deficient in essential nutrients. We're ageing too quickly. We're not getting enough collagen. We need another supplement, another treatment or another routine.

Could this constant messaging be changing how we view our own health and, potentially, how we feel?

There's an interesting psychological phenomenon that might help us explore this: the nocebo effect.

We've heard of the placebo effect, but what about the nocebo effect?

Most of us are familiar with the placebo effect.

It's the phenomenon where someone's expectation that a treatment will work can contribute to a positive response, even when the treatment itself contains no active therapeutic ingredient.

The nocebo effect is essentially the opposite.

It describes how negative expectations, beliefs and suggestions can contribute to experiencing unpleasant symptoms or make existing symptoms feel worse.

For example, if someone is told to expect certain side effects from a treatment, they may become more aware of those sensations and, in some circumstances, experience symptoms associated with that expectation.

Importantly, these symptoms can be very real. The fact that expectations and psychological processes contribute to an experience doesn't mean someone is imagining it.

This isn't simply a theory. Research has demonstrated that negative expectations can influence pain, nausea, itching and other physical sensations.

A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis published in Health Psychology examined 130 studies involving more than 8,200 participants. It found a medium-sized overall nocebo effect, demonstrating that negative expectations can have a measurable influence across different health outcomes.

Read the research: The Nocebo Effect Across Health Outcomes.

So, what does this have to do with social media?

The problem with being constantly told something is wrong with us

Think about a typical scroll through Instagram or TikTok.

You might start by looking for a skincare recommendation and end up watching videos telling you:

  • Your skin is ageing because you're losing collagen.
  • Your hormones are responsible for your tiredness.
  • Your gut microbiome is out of balance.
  • Your body is inflamed.
  • You're deficient in magnesium.
  • Your morning routine is damaging your skin barrier.
  • You need to detox your liver.
  • You're not doing enough to protect yourself against ageing.

Some of these subjects are legitimate areas of health research. Hormones do influence our bodies, nutrition matters, our gut microbiome plays an important role in health and skin ageing is a natural biological process.

The problem isn't discussing these subjects.

It's the way they're increasingly presented as problems that every one of us needs to solve.

Health information becomes marketing. Normal biological changes become symptoms of dysfunction. Natural ageing becomes something to fight. And ordinary variations in how we feel become potential signs that something is wrong.

Before long, we can find ourselves searching for problems we hadn't even considered before.

A new skincare concern leads to another product. A video about hormonal imbalance sends us looking for supplements. A post about inflammation makes us question everything we're eating.

We move from simply wanting to look after ourselves to constantly monitoring ourselves.

And that distinction matters.

Could social media be amplifying the nocebo effect?

We need to be careful here. There isn't sufficient evidence to say that scrolling through social media directly causes the nocebo effect in the same way it has been demonstrated in controlled experiments.

However, there is an interesting connection worth considering.

A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis explored how social learning can influence the nocebo effect.

Social learning is how we develop expectations and beliefs by observing other people's experiences.

The researchers examined 20 studies involving 1,388 participants. Their findings suggested that observing others' negative experiences could contribute to negative expectations and nocebo responses.

Read the research: The Effect of Social Learning on the Nocebo Effect.

Now consider how social media works.

We are constantly exposed to other people's experiences, opinions, symptoms, diagnoses and health concerns.

We watch people describe how they discovered they were intolerant to certain foods, how they identified a hormonal imbalance or how a particular supplement supposedly transformed their health.

We hear repeated warnings about ingredients, products and everyday habits.

It's possible that this constant exposure influences what we expect from our own bodies.

We become more alert to symptoms, more concerned about normal bodily changes and more likely to interpret everyday experiences through the lens of what we've been told.

A little bloating becomes a gut health problem. A few more wrinkles become evidence of collagen loss. Feeling tired after a busy week becomes a possible sign of hormonal dysfunction.

Of course, these symptoms can sometimes indicate genuine health issues. They shouldn't automatically be dismissed.

But equally, we shouldn't be conditioned to assume that every change in our body represents something that needs correcting.

The wellness industry: selling us the problem and the solution

There's a bigger conversation here about the commercialisation of wellness.

An industry that promotes health should ideally help us understand our bodies, make informed decisions and feel more confident about looking after ourselves.

But there's a business model that works rather differently.

First, identify a problem.

Then convince us that it's more common, more serious or more urgent than we realised.

Finally, sell us the solution.

It might be a supplement, a skincare product, a treatment, a detox programme or a new wellness routine.

And just as we become comfortable with one solution, another problem appears.

We are encouraged to believe that we're always one purchase away from feeling better, looking younger or becoming a healthier version of ourselves.

The difficulty is that this approach can create a never-ending cycle of dissatisfaction.

We stop appreciating what our bodies do for us and start focusing on everything they supposedly aren't doing properly.

This isn't an argument against supplements, skincare or taking an active interest in our health. There are circumstances where supplements are beneficial, skincare can support skin health and medical treatment is essential.

But there should be a reason behind what we choose to use, rather than simply reacting to another piece of marketing designed to make us feel inadequate.

When health awareness becomes health anxiety

There is a difference between being informed about your health and becoming preoccupied with it.

Being aware of changes in your body is sensible. Seeking medical advice when something concerns you is important.

But constantly searching for explanations, checking symptoms and comparing yourself with other people's experiences can become exhausting.

You might recognise this pattern:

You notice something about your body.

You search for an explanation online.

You find several possible conditions or deficiencies.

You become concerned that one of them might apply to you.

You start monitoring yourself more closely.

You find another video that reinforces your concerns.

And the cycle continues.

This doesn't mean that every health concern is anxiety or that symptoms should be ignored. It simply highlights how information, expectation and attention can influence our relationship with our health.

We need to be able to access good health information without feeling that we're constantly under threat.

What if we changed the conversation?

Perhaps it's time to question the messages we're allowing into our daily lives.

Instead of constantly asking what we need to fix, could we start asking what our bodies actually need?

Instead of treating every sign of ageing as a problem, could we learn to understand and support the natural ageing process?

Instead of buying supplements because someone on social media tells us we're deficient, could we look at our diet, consider whether there's a genuine need and seek appropriate professional advice?

Instead of layering more and more skincare products onto our faces, could we simplify our routines and focus on supporting our skin barrier?

And instead of following accounts that make us feel we're never doing enough, could we choose sources that educate, inform and empower us?

We don't need to know everything about every possible health condition. We don't need a supplement for every bodily function or a product for every perceived imperfection.

Sometimes the most beneficial thing we can do is step back from the constant noise.

You are not a project that needs fixing

At Ermana, we talk a lot about the relationship between our skin, gut, hormones and mental wellbeing.

We believe in understanding the science behind our bodies, making informed choices and taking responsibility for our health.

But there's an important distinction between supporting our health and constantly searching for something wrong with us.

Our bodies are incredibly complex. They change throughout our lives. Our skin changes, our hormones fluctuate, our energy levels vary and our nutritional needs evolve.

That doesn't automatically mean we're broken.

We should absolutely address genuine health concerns, investigate persistent symptoms and seek evidence-based advice when we need it.

But we should also recognise that health isn't about achieving some permanently optimised version of ourselves.

Perhaps we need to spend less time looking for what's wrong with us and more time appreciating what is right.

Because if we're constantly being told that we need fixing, we risk spending our lives feeling that we're never quite enough.

You are not a never-ending improvement project.

Sometimes, looking after yourself starts with changing the messages you allow yourself to believe.

Research references

  1. Rooney et al. (2024), The Nocebo Effect Across Health Outcomes: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Read research.

  2. Saunders et al. (2024), The Effect of Social Learning on the Nocebo Effect. Read research.

  3. Rooney et al. (2023), The Relationship Between Expectancy, Anxiety, and the Nocebo Effect. Read research.

Photo by Kev Costello on Unsplash

 

Comments (0)

Leave a comment